[He makes an "mm" sound of agreement. Yeah, he wasn't fond of how that turned out either.]

So that's how we met. Memory loss is a common occurrence with supernatural incidents even without memory spells, so I already anticipated that you wouldn't remember. Usually I don't bother telling people who've forgotten that we've met before, but...

...Well, even for me it's not every day you see a dead man walking.

[So he was surprised!]